
Mc Camley's Third Law was "when people say 'it's not about the money', it is". An alternative version is "when people say they don't want power, they do".
I was thinking of this last nigth watching Would You Believe on RTE, yet another RTE programme about how awful the Church is and how wonderful it would be if only liberals ruled the Church as well as the world. There was a panel of about twenty. The programme opened with a five minute filmed section about how awful the Church was and how wonderful it would be if liberals ruled it and then went straight to Bishop John McAreavey who wasn't asked a question but simply to respond, an almost impossible task. Bishops have no chance on these programmes because they feel unable to come out and say the things that need to be said: Christ founded the Church on a hierarchical basis with the Pope, bishops etc. The Pope is infallible. Women can't be ordained and it's heresy if you say otherwise. Homosexual acts are gravely sinful. Instead they feel forced into rather pious structural speak which invariably misleads. They suspect there will be structural changes after the visitation - but what they fear is the abolition of their dioceses. So they talk about parish councils. In the circumstances Bishop McAreavey and Bishop Kirby did their best. while Bishop Willie Walshe did his best to undermine them.
The rest of the panel comprised three orthodox Cahholics who were each allowed to speak once, and fifteen liberals who were allowed to spout forth endlessly. Some at least were clear in that they wanted the Church to abandon it's two thousand year teaching on the inability of women to receive holy orders and homosexuality. Others, Baroness O'Loan and Mary O'Rourke, wittered endlessly about listening, and opening and women, and change and structures - but with nothing concrete to propose. In both cases I got the feeling we had women who had exercised high office in their chosen field and resented not being able to do the same in the Church. And of course we had the tremendous hypocrisy which saw the Holy Father being attacked for exercising his office - "it's supposed to be about service and love and Jesus - not about power and authority" and in the next breath, "women are powerless". But it's not about power.
As usual the so called journalists were among the worst - Patsy McGarry and Michael Kelly, the Irish Catholic deputy plagiarist.
The silliest gimmick was getting four of the liberals to write to the Pope with their ideas. "I wonder will they get the courtesy of a response". Well in the case of the Jesuit I hope he gets a slap.
If only Otto Preminger's Cardinal could have appeared in full pontificals. Really going on the back foot doesn't work with these people. You can't apologise and you can't explain.
On a trivial note, wikipedia claims that Ratzinger had some official role in the filming of The Cardinal.
Posted by Christopher Mc. Posted In :
Church